马德琳·麦卡恩失踪事件

马德琳·麦卡恩失踪事件是2007年5月3日晚发生在葡萄牙阿尔加维普拉亚·达·卢什英语Praia da Luz的一件女童失踪案。女童名叫马德琳·贝丝·麦卡恩(英语:Madeleine Beth McCann,2003年5月12日),当时只有三岁。此案是现代历史上最知名的人口失踪案之一,麦卡恩的行踪至今不明。[2]

马德琳·麦卡恩
2007年马德琳3岁时的照片,右侧是法庭素描师推测出2012年马德琳9岁的样子[1]
出生马德琳·贝丝·麦卡恩
(2003-05-12)2003年5月12日
 英国莱斯特
失踪2007年5月3日(3岁)
 葡萄牙普拉亚·达·卢什英语Praia da Luz5A Rua Dr Agostinho da Silva
37°05′19″N 8°43′51″W / 37.0886565°N 8.7308398°W / 37.0886565; -8.7308398
失踪情况已失踪17年6个月又5天
父母格里·麦卡恩
凯特·麦卡恩(本姓希利)
特征金色直发;左眼绿蓝色;右眼绿色虹膜上有明显斑点;左小腿上有小型褐色胎记
调查者葡萄牙司法警察
莱斯特郡警察
伦敦警察厅苏格兰场
联系Operation Grange(苏格兰场);玛德琳基金会

玛德琳当时正在葡萄牙与父母凯特(Kate)和格里·麦卡恩(Gerry McCann)及其他家庭成员一起度假。其父母在晚上八时半离开在公寓一楼睡觉的她和其孪生胞弟前往50米(160英尺)外的餐厅就餐。[3] 晚上10点时其母发现玛德琳失踪,葡萄牙警方最初认为这是一起诱拐绑架案,但后来误读英国发出的DNA分析报告而误判玛德琳已经死亡。[4] 2007年9月其父母被怀疑谋杀了女孩,但次年7月得以澄清,当月葡萄牙司法部长宣布结案。[5]

在2011年5月苏格兰场在英国内政大臣的要求下宣布展开格兰赫行动(Operation Grange)介入调查前,麦卡恩夫妇一直雇用私人侦探进行调查。2013年10月葡萄牙警方也开始重新调查此案,当月苏格兰场发布了嫌犯的电子合成照片,其中一张照片显示一名男子携带着玛德琳在事发当晚走向沙滩。此外包括J·K·罗琳在内的社会各界人士给此案提供了悬赏金。[6]

这桩失踪案引发了广泛的国际关注。麦卡恩夫妇在玛德琳失踪后被错误地认为涉嫌谋杀而遭到来自推特和各种小报的人身攻击,[7] 2008年他们收到了赔偿金及来自英国出版商北壳集团的道歉,这也导致要求限制新闻舆论的声音增强。[8][9]2020年,德国检察官假定马德琳·麦卡恩死亡,并且表示一名43岁德国籍连环性侵犯“克里斯坦·B(Christian B)”涉有重嫌。[10]

背景

编辑

人物

编辑

玛德琳麦卡恩

编辑
 
红色部分为葡萄牙,北部和西部临近西班牙,南部临近摩洛哥

玛德琳出生于2003年5月12日,住在英国莱斯特洛斯雷英语Rothley。她拥有着金发碧眼,在侧小腿有小形棕色胎记,因患有虹膜异色症,导致双眼呈现蓝色和绿色,并在右眼的绿色虹膜上有一条独特的深色条纹[11]。2009年,英国警方为麦卡恩夫妇提供了一张玛德琳6岁的年代进展图英语age progression,并在2012年提供了9岁的[12][13]

凯特和格里麦卡恩

编辑

玛德琳的父母均为罗马天主教徒。母亲凯特麦卡恩先后就读于安菲尔德的诸圣学校和埃弗顿谷的圣母高中,并于 1992 年毕业于邓迪大学,获得医学学位。她曾短暂地进入了妇产科,然后再进入了麻醉科,最后是全科[14]

父亲格里麦卡恩于1968年出生于格拉斯哥,曾就读于荷里路德中学英语Holyrood Secondary School,并在1989年从格拉斯哥大学毕业完成生理学/运动科学学士学位。1992 年,他获得了医学资格,并于 2002 年获得了来自格拉斯哥的医学博士学位。2005 年以来,他一直是莱斯特格伦菲尔德医院英语Glenfield Hospital的心脏病专家顾问[15] 。麦卡恩夫妇于 1993 年在格拉斯哥相识,并于 1998 年结婚。有三个孩子,分别是2003年出生玛德琳和2005年出生的龙凤胎西恩(Sean)和艾米莉(Emelie) [16]

塔帕斯七人

编辑

麦卡恩夫妇在案发当时在与七个朋友和八个孩子一起度假,其中包括玛德琳和玛德琳弟妹[17]。晚上20:30九位大人一般都在度假村的塔帕斯餐厅一起用餐,因此媒体将这七个大人为“塔帕斯七人” [18]。塔帕斯七人中包括菲奥娜和大卫佩恩斯,他们都是医生,他们家庭中前往的成员包括他们的两个孩子以及菲奥娜的母亲黛安韦珀斯特。麦卡恩与佩恩斯相识多年。凯特在2000年在莱斯特综合医院的重症监护室工作时认识菲奥娜[19]。陪同他们的是佩恩斯最初介绍给麦卡恩家族的两对夫妇,营销经理简·坦纳 (Jane Tanner) 和她的合伙人、医生拉塞尔·奥布莱恩 (Russell O'Brien),他们都带着两个孩子去度假,以及另一位医生马修·奥德菲尔德 (Matthew Oldfield)与他的妻子、律师雷切尔·奥尔德菲尔德和他们的女儿在一起。多年来,格里、拉塞尔和马修一直在一起工作[17][18]。根据简.唐纳的报告,她曾看到一名男子从45分钟前报导玛德琳度假村携带孩子带走失踪成为案件的最讨论方面之一[20]

案发地点

编辑

2007年4月28日,麦卡恩一家抵达葡萄牙阿尔加维大区普拉亚达卢兹英语Praia da Luz村,开启为期七个夜晚的春假。普拉亚达卢兹村人口1000,因是英国人度假定居的热门地点,固有“小英国”之称[21]。麦卡恩一家通过英国度假公司马克·华纳公司英语Mark Warner Ltd租下阿戈斯蒂尼奥·达席尔瓦英语Agostinho da Silva博士路5A的一间公寓,房东为利物浦的一位退休教师[22]

公寓位于地下层,有两间卧室,属于水边村(Waterside Village)公寓群的第五栋,地处马克华纳公司旗下海洋俱乐部(Ocean Club)度假村的附近[23]。麦卡恩一家的邻居有住在5B的马修和蕾切尔·奥德菲尔德(Matthew and Rachel Oldfield)、5D的珍·坦纳和罗素·奥布莱恩(Jane Tanner and Russell O'Brien),以及同栋一楼的佩恩斯和黛安·韦珀斯特(Paynes and Dianne Webster)[24]。由于处在阿戈斯蒂尼奥·达席尔瓦博士路和弗朗西斯科·让蒂尔·马丁斯博士英语Francisco Gentil路的交界处,外人可以从两边进入5A[25]。从客厅后方的滑动玻璃露台门可俯瞰海洋俱乐部的游泳池、网球场、小吃餐厅和酒吧,也可以前往公用的让蒂尔·马丁斯博士路,来到通往5A栋阳台及客厅的小门及台阶。5A栋的前门则位于达席尔瓦博士路海洋俱乐部街区的对面[26][27]

麦凯恩的两个孩子睡靠近的前门的卧室,房门一直被麦凯恩一家锁住。卧室有一个带窗帘的齐腰高窗户,窗帘后是一个在外面的百叶窗,由窗内的绳索控制。整个假期里,麦凯恩一直拉上百叶窗和窗帘。从窗户可以俯瞰狭窄的人行道和居民停车场,后者有一堵矮墙和道路分开[28]。马德琳睡在靠近卧室房门、窗户对面的单人床,同时双胞胎的旅行婴儿床放在房间中间,窗下还有一张单人床[26]

案发过程

编辑

白天:麦卡恩家庭活动

编辑

5月3日星期四是麦卡恩一家假期的倒数第二。吃完早餐,玛德琳问:“昨天晚上(哥哥)和我哭的时候,你们怎么没有过来?”玛德琳失踪后,父母怀疑这句话意味着晚上有人进了他们的房间。另外,母亲注意到马德琳睡衣上衣有一个很大的棕色污点[29]

上午,父母带两个孩子在度假村的儿童俱乐部(Kids' Club)玩,中午在公寓吃午饭,之后到泳池玩水[26]。下午2点29分,凯特给玛德琳拍了最后一张公开的照片,当时玛德琳与父亲及两岁的妹妹坐在泳池边[30]。之后孩子回到儿童俱乐部,当晚6点和母亲回到5A,父亲则去上网球课[26]。晚上7点左右,父母哄孩子们上床睡觉,玛德琳穿着玛莎百货的粉白相间屹耳短袖睡衣,旁边有一条安抚巾,还有毛绒玩具抱抱猫(Cuddle Cat)[31]

晚上8点30分:小吃餐厅

编辑

晚上8点30分,夫妇俩离开5A,陪朋友到海洋俱乐部泳池边的露天小吃餐厅吃饭[32]。5A与餐厅直线距离英语as the crow flies55米(180英尺),但去餐厅要走过一条公用道路,来到海洋俱乐部度假村的大门,之后再穿过度假村到泳池另一边,全程82米(295英尺)[33]。从公寓楼楼顶可以看到小吃餐厅,但看不到大门。由于露台的门只能从里面锁,麦卡恩一直拉上门,但没有锁,窗帘也拉开,方便他们随时回去观察孩子的动态。露台台阶顶部有一个儿童安全锁,底部有一扇矮门,矮门通向大街[32]

度假村员工在泳池接待区的留言簿留下一条字条,要求在麦卡恩一家假期最后四晚的晚上8点半给夫妇俩及朋友预订能俯瞰公寓的那张桌子,方便家长们监督在公寓里睡觉的孩子。案发后,凯特推测绑匪看过那张字条[34]。大约每隔半个小时,麦卡恩夫妇和朋友会回去看孩子。当晚9点05分左右,盖瑞第一次回5A看孩子。据他回忆,当时孩子睡得很沉很安稳,但原本虚掩的房间全开了,于是他把门关上,之后回到餐厅[32]

晚上9点15分:坦纳的发现

编辑

小吃餐厅七人组的简·坦纳注意到一名带着孩子的男子,她的发现成为早期调查的关键。当时是晚上9点,坦纳离开餐厅,回去看完女儿,途径让蒂尔·马丁斯博士路时碰到加里,后者9点05分回去查看完,正在回餐厅的路上。加里停下了和一位英国的度假旅客聊天[35],但两个人都不记得见过坦纳。由于博士路比较窄,葡萄牙警方听完坦纳的证词觉得十分困惑,开始指责坦纳编造了目击事件[36]

据坦纳向警方表示,大约9点15分,她注意眼前有一名男子正带着一个小朋友路过让蒂尔·马丁斯路和达席尔瓦路交界的十字路口。男子离玛德琳的睡房不远,一直往5A公寓前门反方向朝东走去[37]。在最初的调查中,男子步行方向成为关键系哪所,因为他正朝33岁英裔葡萄牙男子罗伯特·穆拉特的家走去,而他的家就在5A附近,所以穆拉特成为本案第一嫌疑人[38][20][39]

男子怀里抱着的孩子穿着一件浅粉色睡衣,裤腿及袖口处有花卉的图案,与玛德琳所穿的衣服类似。坦纳形容这个男子白皮肤、黑发、身高1.7米(5.7英尺)、35到40岁左右,从相貌上看似南欧人或地中海沿岸地区人。男子上身穿着一件黑色夹克,下身是一条金色(或浅褐色)的裤子,完全不是游客的打扮。凯特表示,玛德琳报告失踪后,坦纳就将这条消息告诉给葡萄牙警方,对方直到5月25日才向媒体公开了情况[40]。玛德琳基金会请了一位法庭画家画这名男子的素描,于2007年10月公开[41][42]

凭借这个重要的发现,调查人员确认了案发时间,但苏格兰场的人认为男子抱着的是红鲱鱼[43]。2013年10月,苏格兰场将坦纳看到的男子认定为一名英国度假者,当时这位度假者回海洋俱乐部的夜间托儿所接女儿回公寓[44]。他们让度假者穿上跟当晚一样和类似的衣服,用坦纳所述的姿势站着,拍下他的照片。男子女儿所穿的睡衣和坦纳报告的一样。农庄行动(Operation Grange)首席警探、总督察安迪·雷德伍德(Andy Redwood)表示,他们“几乎可以确认”坦纳所见与绑架案无关[43][45]

晚上10点:史密斯的发现

编辑

否认坦纳的发现对确认案发时间非常重要后,调查人员把重心放在当晚另一位带着孩子的男子身上。这位男子由马丁和玛丽·史密斯2007年5月26日向葡萄牙警方报告[46]。2013年,苏格兰场认为史密斯夫妇的发现确定了玛德琳被绑架的大概时间[6][47]

晚上10点左右,史密斯夫妇在离麦卡恩公寓500码(460米)的小学街(Rua da Escola Primária)看到一名男子离开海洋俱乐部前往4月25日街(Rua 25 de Abril)和沙滩,带着一名约莫三四岁的女孩。女孩棕色头发、白皮肤,穿着浅色睡衣,光着脚,男子30岁左右,1米75到1米8(5.7英尺到7.5英尺),身材苗条,棕色短发,穿着奶油色或米色长裤[48][49]。在麦卡恩夫妇的聘请下,奥克利国际(Oakley International)于2008年根据史密斯夫妇的证词生成男子的电脑合成影像英语E-FIT,后来苏格兰场于2013年在英国广播公司英国犯罪观察英语Crimewatch》上首次公开该图像[50]

晚上10点:失踪报告

编辑

凯特原本要在9点30分回去看孩子,但七人组中的马修·奥德费尔德也要去旁边的5A看孩子,顺道看了凯特的孩子。马修发现麦卡恩家的儿童房房门打开,但里头没有动静传出。马修没有进房间看玛德琳在不在,也记不清房间窗户和外面的百叶窗当时有没有打开。在早期的调查中,葡萄牙警方指责奥德费尔德参与其中,因为他自愿提出帮忙看孩子,有可能通过睡房窗户将玛德琳递给其他人[26][51]

晚上10点左右,凯特回5A检查。苏格兰场于2013年表示玛德琳可能这在这个时间点之前被人带走的[52]。据凯特会议,她通过公寓后面未上锁的露台门进入,发现孩子们的睡房房门打开。就在她打算关门的时候,一股强劲的气流砰的一下关上了房门,由此看到睡房窗户和百叶窗打开着。玛德琳的摇篮猫和毛巾还在床上,人倒是不见了。稍微检查完公寓,凯特急忙跑回餐厅,大喊“玛德琳丢了!有人带走了她!”[53]

大约10点10分,加里派马修·奥德费尔德去度假村的接待处报警,10点30分度假村启动失踪儿童搜索机制[54],出动60名员工及游客四处找人,直至凌晨4点30分。最初大家认为玛德琳迷路了,其中一人向第四台新闻快递英语Dispatches (TV programme)》栏目表示整个卢什都可以听到搜索人员在叫玛德琳的名字[55]

初期反应

编辑

葡萄牙警方行动

编辑

国家宪兵共和国国民警卫队英语Guarda Nacional Republicana的两名警察从5英里(8公里)远的拉古什赶来,晚上11点10分抵达度假村[56]。结束完凌晨的简要搜查,他们通报了附近波尔蒂芒司法警察。凯特回忆司法警察在凌晨1点刚过的时候到场[57]。根据警察所述,接警不到10分钟,他们就抵达现场[58]。凌晨2点,警方把两条巡逻犬带到度假村,8点出动了四条嗅探犬[59]。他们取消了假期,将卢兹的下水道、水井、洞穴和废墟翻了个遍[21][60]。波尔蒂芒总督察贡萨洛·阿马拉尔担任调查总指挥[61]

众所周知,警方在案发后的“黄金时间”内犯了很多错误,边防机构水上警察有好几个小时没有接到玛德琳的情况,警方也没有每户上门搜查[62][63]。凯特表示警方到了第二天早上10点才设路障[48]。警方没有要求提供案发当晚离开卢兹的车辆监控画面,也没有要求提供西班牙边境地带拉各斯及圣安东尼奥雷阿尔城车辆画面。负责道路监控的公司Euroscut表示警方没有找他们要信息[64]国际刑警组织花了五天时间,才行发布全球失踪人口警告英语Interpol notice[48]。另外,警方也没有采访案发当时在度假村的所有,度假者也是后来才跟英国警方说没有联系过他们[63]

犯罪现场未收到保护。葡萄牙警方采集了玛德琳睡房的样本,把样本送去三个法医实验室验证。据司法警察总督察奥莱加里奥·德·索萨(Olegário de Sousa)表示,2007年6月1日,警方找到一位“陌生人”的DNA,但房间关门前有大约20人进入5A公寓[65][36]。凯特表示,凌晨3点有位警官在儿童房的门口贴上的胶带,之后就离开了,没有保护好现场[57]。根据司警2008年发布的文件,案发一个月后,5A一直处于闲置状态,之后于2007年8月被封锁,方便进行后续的调查搜证[22][66]。公寓外面也出现了类似的情况,一大群人聚焦在5A公寓的前门,包括儿童睡房窗户的旁边(这里极有可能是绑匪进入或离开的地方),踩踏了证据[67]。一位警察在没有戴手套或穿防护衣的情况下在窗户外面的百叶窗扫指纹[36]

Panoramic view of Praia da Luz, February 2015

英国警方行动

编辑

玛德琳家乡的莱斯特郡警察英语Leicestershire Police在同意的情况下派出特遣队,负责协调英方的行动。行动队伍由地区警察局局长英语Chief Constable马特·巴戈特英语Matt Baggott率领,与葡萄牙方的调查同期进行[68]。双方组成了一个代表战术协调小组(或称金色小组英语Gold–silver–bronze command structure),由莱斯特郡警察、严重及有组织犯罪调查局儿童剥削和网络保护中心英语Child Exploitation and Online Protection Centre国家警察改进署英语National Police Improvement Agency的代表组成。司法警察明面上给英方提供了一个工作房间,暗地里不满他们前来。英方习惯把资料输入到内政部大型重要查询系统,葡方则用箱子搜集资料。另外,葡方没有英方那样的自治权,一般要等候裁判官做决定,工作效率大大降低。在安东尼·桑默斯英语Anthony Summers罗宾·斯旺英语Robbyn Swan的《寻找玛德琳》(Looking for Madeleine,2014)一书中,时任儿童剥削和网络保护中心主任吉姆·甘布尔英语Jim Gamble表示葡萄牙觉得他们屈尊于英国这样的“殖民大国”[69]

媒体与公关

编辑
 
Tribute in Rothley英语Rothley, the McCanns' home town, on 17 May 2007

2010年,葡萄牙司法警察的一名官员承认他们在“媒体马戏团”的影响下,从一开始就怀疑麦卡恩一家[70]。2008年,加里向《名利场》杂志表示,他曾决定“推销”玛德琳,让她一直受到公众的关注。结果,在当地警方的极为不满、认为媒体关注会有反作用之下,一群公共关系顾问来到卢玆[21]。英国公关机构贝尔波特廷格英语Bell Pottinger的亚历克斯·伍尔法(Alex Woolfall)在案发前十天一直代表马克·华纳公司跟媒体打交道,之后英国政府也派了新闻官,情况前所未见[71]

在《每日镜报》当记者的新闻官雪莉·多德(Sheree Dodd)率先抵达,之后中央信息办公室英语Central Office of Information的克拉伦斯·米切尔(Clarence Mitchell)主任抵达。英方召回米切尔后,麦卡恩一家又在猎头的帮助下聘请了贾斯婷·麦吉尼斯(Justine McGuinness)。贾斯婷离开后,由首相约翰·梅杰前私人秘书查尔斯·莱文顿(Charles Lewington)持有的汉诺威通讯(Hanover Communications)进场[72][73]。2007年9月,圣母峰之窗英语Everest Windows布赖恩·肯尼迪(Brian Kennedy)提出支付米切尔的薪水,方便她回来。随后米切尔辞去公职,全职投入麦卡恩一家的工作,由玛德琳基金会支付薪水[74][75]

2007年5月15日,麦卡恩一家创立玛德琳基金会:不遗余力有限公司,用以筹集资金,提高大家对事件的关注。基金会网站上线两天就获得5800万次点击[76]。5月和6月,玛德琳夫妇的公关团队安排了几项活动,维持媒体对案件的关注,包括前往葡萄牙花地玛[21]、荷兰、德国、西班牙[77]和摩洛哥[78]。2007年5月30日,在记者的陪同下,夫妇俩乘坐菲利普·格林英语Philip Green爵士的里尔喷射机飞到罗马,在威斯敏斯特大主教英语Archbishop of Westminster的安排下接见教宗本笃十六世[77]。次月,世界各地300座城市放飞了玛德琳的气球[79]

马修·帕里斯英语Matthew Parris表示,到6月初,记者们开始担忧专业的公关活动影响到采访[80]。若以玛德琳事件为头版,一份英国报纸最多可以卖3万份[21]。2007年5月28日,玛德琳登上人物杂志封面[81],之后在英国各大小报的头版上出现了几乎六个月,甚至天空新闻台的菜单选项也为玛德琳开辟了专区[21][82]。2007年5月到2008年7月间,葡萄牙小报《晨邮报英语Correio da Manhã》共发布玛德琳的文章384篇[83]。到2008年6月,在YouTube上搜索玛德琳会出现3680条视频及700百万条贴文[84]

葡萄牙方调查

编辑

头号嫌疑人

编辑

玛德琳失踪12天后,34岁的英国葡萄牙裔置业顾问罗伯特·穆拉特(Robert Murat)成为案件的首位嫌疑人[85][86]。穆拉特生于西伦敦汉默史密斯,住在母亲的“莉莲娜之家”(Casa Liliana),该处距5A公寓150码(137米),就位于坦纳目击男子所走的方向[85]。《星期日镜报》一位记者跟警察说穆拉特一直在问案件的情况后,警方将他列为嫌疑人。有一段时间,穆拉特是与司法警察签约的官方口译员。穆拉特说自己之所以帮忙,是因为在英国女儿也跟玛德琳一样大[87][88]

小吃餐厅七人组中的菲欧娜·佩恩、拉塞尔·奥布莱恩和蕾切尔·奥德费尔德表示案发后不久看到穆拉特在5A公寓外,当时公寓外还有海洋俱乐部的一位保姆和两位英国度假者。考虑到穆拉特的住所临近5A,他的出现并不奇怪,但是他说自己和母亲整晚都呆在家里[89][90]。然而,麦卡恩家的身边人仍对穆拉特持怀疑态度:其中一位支持麦卡恩一家的人告诉BBC记者理查德·比尔顿(Richard Bilton),说可以提供案件的任何最新进展,前提是比尔顿的报道需要包括新闻界对穆拉特的看法[91]。从2007年5月15日开始,警方开始搜查穆拉特的家,排空了游泳池的水,检查了他的汽车、电脑、手机及监控录像,利用金属探测器与嗅探犬搜查了他的花园,询问了他两个手下[85][92]。2008年3月,其中一位助理放火烧了穆拉特的车子,并在人行道上用红漆写上“Fala”(说话)一词[93]。由于穆拉特及其朋友与失踪事件没有联系,警方于2008年7月21日结案时解除了他的嫌疑[94]。2008年4月,穆拉特发起诽谤官司达成庭外和解,其本人获得60万欧元的赔偿金;《观察家报》表示赔偿金是英国单一诽谤官司的最大庭外和解金。穆拉特的好友各获得10万欧元赔偿[95]。2014年7月格兰赫行动期间,穆拉特的其中一位好友以目击者身份受审,审问者是苏格兰场委托的司法警察[96]。同年12月,穆拉特与妻子及其他八人受审,审问者同样是苏格兰场的代表[97]。2017年,穆拉特母亲作为当晚5A附近可疑事件的目击者发声。据她向英国广播公司表示,当晚她驾车路过5A公寓,发现一位身穿梅色上衣、举止可疑的年轻女子就在门外,之后便将相关情报告诉给警察。另外,她还看到一辆棕色的小型出租汽车在单行道上逆行,飞速驶向公寓方向[98]

目击者证词

编辑

在写给司法警察的证词中,多位目击者表示案发前夕及当天有几个举止怪异的男子出现在5A公寓附近。苏格兰场推测这几个人可能会为绑架或入室盗窃进行踩点。2007年1月到5月间,当地的入室盗窃案增长近四倍,而麦卡恩一家所在的大楼案发前一周就发生了两起,犯人通过窗户入室[43][99]

另有目击者称有男子是在进行募捐。4月20日,一位衣衫不整的男子向一位住在5A附近的女游客讨钱,说是要在埃斯皮切英语Espiche附近建一家孤儿院,而埃斯皮切当时并没有孤儿院而类似的地方。目击者表示这名男子态度咄咄逼人,令人害怕[100]。4月25日、26日左右,在麦卡恩一家之前租住5A的游客发现一名男子出现在阳台,是通过台阶从街上进入的[101]。这名男子非常礼貌,胡子刮得非常干净,向游客索要建孤儿院的钱[102]。案发当天,上述两名男子在5A附近的街道四次募捐[101]。当天下午4点,两名黑发男子接触一位英国租客,索要在埃斯皮切附近设立旅馆或安宁病房;下午5点,两名男子与另一位英国游客接触,双方经历类似[103]

5月2日,有人在5A对面街看到一名“相貌丑陋”的棕发男子,男子明显盯着5A看。早在4月29日,有人在海洋俱乐部看到他。4月30日,5A前房客的孙女看到一位棕发男子靠在公寓后的墙,5月2日又在小吃餐厅看到他,当时他正望向5A。孙女称这名男子是白人,年纪约30岁,短发,脸上有斑点.[104][105]。案发前天及当天,一名男子盯着麦卡恩的街区看,附近有一辆白色小货车[105]。5月3日傍晚时分,住在5A上方的一位女孩从阳台看到一名男子从大门处离开,仿佛是从地面层的公寓离开。让她在意的是,男子走出大门时四处张望,用双手轻轻关上大门[106]。14点30分,两名金发男子出现在5C的阳台,此处隔5A两扇门,暂无人租住。下午4点到5点,两名金发男子出现在5A附近。晚6点,同一名或另一名金发男子在麦卡恩所在大楼的楼梯间出现。晚11点,也就是麦卡恩失踪后,两名金发男子在附近街头出现,说话声调很高。被人发现的时候,两人降低声调并走开[107]

麦卡恩夫妇的嫌疑

编辑

早期嫌疑

编辑

早在2007年6月6日,媒体就开始怀疑麦卡恩夫妇,当时一名德国记者在柏林的记者会上问到两人是否涉及案件[108][109]。6月30日,葡萄牙周报《太阳报英语Sol (newspaper)》刊发3000字文章《玛德琳案:封口条约》,直言麦卡恩夫妇就是嫌犯,强调两人的说法前后不一,而坦纳的目击证词也是纯属捏造[110]。该报记者取得塔帕斯七人及另一位目击者的手机号码,证明调查行动已被泄露[35][109][111]。《太阳报》这一篇和之后的报道在没有证据的情况下提出多项指控,这些指控得到英国媒体密切跟进,让麦卡恩在之后几年面临社交媒体的口诛笔伐。相关指控包括麦卡恩夫妇和塔帕斯七人组玩“交换配偶”、麦卡恩夫妇给自己的孩子服用镇静剂、麦卡恩夫妇和塔帕斯七人组就案发当晚的情况达成了“封口条约”[87]。除此之外,夫妇俩与塔帕斯七人组的证词也出现了大量前后不一或互相矛盾的地方。警方要求一行人接受葡萄牙语提问,一行人的回答由口译员翻译成葡萄牙语。据凯特表示,这些证词随后会用葡萄牙语打印出来,由口译员翻译成英语,被审问人了解后签字确认[51][87]

另一个前后不一致的地方是回去查看孩子的情况的时候,麦卡恩夫妇到底有没有从前门/后门进入公寓。据司法警察卷宗记载,格里在2007年5月4日第一次接受询问时表示,他们两夫妻两次从上锁的前门进入5A,一次是晚上9点05分自己那次,一次是晚上10点妻子那次。后来在5月10日第二次询问中,格里改口称是从后方未上锁的露台门进入的[112](由于露台门只能从里面开锁,夫妇俩故意没有锁门,方便后续进入)[32]。而前门到底上没上锁的说法也存在矛盾[112]。据格里2007年12月向英国《星期日泰晤士报》记者透露,那个礼拜早些时候,他们曾经用过前门,但这扇门紧挨着孩子们的睡房。为了不吵到孩子们休息,他们改用露台门进入[36]。司法警察向凯特提出疑问,为什么发现玛德琳失踪的时候要扔下5A的双胞胎跑到餐厅里求救,而不是用手机报警,或者是从5A后方的露台向餐厅里的人叫喊[113]

另一个问题是玛德琳卧室窗户上的外百叶窗是否可以从外面打开。据记者丹尼·科林斯(Danny Collins)透露,这扇百叶窗由有色金属板条制作,板条收纳在窗内顶部的一个盒子里,使用时拉动皮带即可。百叶窗放下来后,上面的板条会股固定在窗外,只能用窗内的带子拉起来[114]。据凯特回忆,玛德琳被叫上床睡觉的时候,百叶窗和窗户都是关着的,但她后来发现玛德琳失踪的时候是开着的。格里告诉司法警察,刚开始他注意到玛德琳失踪的时候,他把百叶窗降了下来,之后走到窗外,发现百叶窗只能从外面升起[115]。对于这一点,葡萄牙警方表示百叶窗在没有施力的情况下无法从外面升起,所以没有强行闯入英语forced entry的迹象。再者,强行把百叶窗拉开会弄出很大的动静[114]

考虑到矛盾的地方过于明显,司法警察有理由认为案件不存在绑架情况[116][117]。凯特当时大喊“他们把她抓走了”也引起一些怀疑,不禁让人觉得她是想让大家误以为有绑架案[36]。需要注意的是,从8月份开始,有关嫌疑衍生出一种说法,认为玛德琳就死在5A公寓,死因是服用过量镇静剂意外死亡。之后父母把她的尸体藏了一个月,案发三个礼拜后用一辆租来的汽车把尸体运到神秘地点抛弃[118][119]。2010年,前葡萄牙警探联盟主席卡洛斯·安乔斯(Carlos Anjos)告诉BBC《广角镜》节目,葡萄牙的警探大多认为玛德琳是在公寓里意外身亡的[120]

葡萄牙方面的委托书

编辑

2007年6月28日,麦卡恩夫妇建议司法警察求助前南非警察丹尼·克鲁格(Danie Krugel),说克鲁格发明了一种名叫“物体定位系统”的手持设备,据说可以用DNA和卫星定位找到失踪人口[36]。多年后一位科学家听闻这件事,说这种探测器是“牛皮吹破天”[121]。凯特在2011年撰写的文章中也认为克鲁格是在吹牛,但麦卡恩夫妇深信不疑。6月第二个礼拜,麦卡恩一家的英国亲戚向克鲁格送来了玛德琳的头发和睫毛。7月15日,克鲁格来到普拉亚达卢什调查,据说是用仪器在罗查内格拉(Rocha Negra)悬崖附近的沙滩找到一个“静态信号”[122][36][123]

负责司法警察调查行动的贡萨洛·阿马拉尔督察认为凯特对克鲁格的支持是烟雾弹,目的是在不损害自身利益的情况下“找出女儿尸体的位置”(她也考虑使用灵媒[124]。带着这个看法,司法警察向英国警方发出委托书,请求协助搜查玛德琳的尸体[36][123]。为此,英国国家警务改进局国家搜索顾问马克·哈里森(Mark Harrison)来到普拉亚达卢什,以徒步及乘坐直升机的方式调查相关地点[125]。哈里森在报告中称克鲁格的做法“非常不靠谱”,表示截至2007年7月23日,有100名警察搜查了普拉亚达卢什周边9.3英里(15千米)的区域;除了里斯本来的搜救队,负责调查的警察及团体的大多数人都没接受过搜索程序训练。搜索人员也用上了搜索犬,但用的时间已经是提出使用的五天后,而不是建议的两天内。哈里森建议搜索海滩及海岸线区域、村子附近的空地、罗伯特·穆拉特的房产、5A公寓、塔帕斯七人组的公寓及涉事租车。他还建议使用透地雷达,用了来自南约克郡的两条史宾格犬Keela和Eddie[126][125]

英国嗅探犬抵达

编辑

凯拉是一条法医调查犬,在主人马丁·格莱姆的训练下,她可以把鼻子凑到案发现场的地面来嗅探人类血液的气味。每当有发现的时候,她会停在原地不动,以此向主人发出“被动警报”。艾迪是一条增强型遇害者搜查犬(也就是搜救犬),每当嗅到尸体气味时,就会发出“吠叫警报”,包括死亡时间不短、埋在地里、火花过或没入水中的尸体。经过专业训练,艾迪只会在闻到尸体气味的时候吠叫,其他情况不会吠[127]

两条搜查犬于2007年7月31日抵达普拉亚达卢什,其后在5A公寓、尸体周围及沙滩处进行搜查。两条犬都在5A客厅沙发后面发出警报,其中艾迪还在主卧衣橱附近发出警报[128][129]。至于沙滩或湿地,两条犬都没有回应[130]。葡萄牙司法警察申请搜查令,对麦卡恩一家在弗洛雷斯街租住的公寓,以及麦卡恩夫妇在玛德琳失踪后租了24天的银色雷诺风景英语Renault Scénic轿车进行搜查。对租用公寓及周围地区的搜查行动于8月2日进行,期间艾迪只对躺在地上的摇篮猫作出反应,凯拉则还有回应[131]。警方带走了麦卡恩一家的衣物、摇篮猫、一副乳胶手套、几个行李箱、一本笔记本、两本日记(包括凯特在女儿失踪后开始写的那本),以及凯特向朋友借来的《圣经》。其中,《圣经》《撒母耳记》第2章中做了标记,这一段是讲一个儿童的死亡,在警方的卷宗中有副本,且附有一段葡萄牙语翻译[132]。上述证物被带到另一个地方,随后艾迪就其中一箱向主人作出反应[133]。接近麦卡恩一家律师团队的消息人士向记者透露,如果凯特的衣服的确有尸体的气味,很有可能是她在做家庭医生接触尸体时染上的[134]

司警也将雷诺风景轿车带走调查[135]。8月6日,基拉和艾迪来到波尔蒂芒司警总部对面的地下停车场。停车场共停放10辆车,每辆车间隔20至30英尺的距离,当中包括麦卡恩一家和穆拉特一家的车[136]。艾迪在麦卡恩一家轿车的驾驶车门外面发出警报[137][129]。第二天早上,基拉对后备箱靠近驾驶员一侧,以及驾驶员车门的地图隔间发出警告,而车门地图隔间放着点火钥匙,以及钥匙圈。当钥匙圈藏在消防桶里的沙子下面时,她再次发出警报,跟消防桶被移到停车场的另一层时一样[138]。几乎同一时间,葡萄牙媒体开始报道玛德琳在5A公寓内死亡[139]

英国方面的DNA分析

编辑

Hair and other fibres were collected from areas in the car and apartment 5A where Keela and Eddie had given alerts, and were sent to the Forensic Science Service英语Forensic Science Service (FSS) in Birmingham for DNA profiling, arriving around 8 August 2007.[140] At this point, according to The Sunday Times, the PJ "abandoned the abduction theory".[36] On 8 August, without waiting for the results from Birmingham, Portuguese police called the McCanns to a meeting in Portimão, where Guilhermino Encarnação, PJ regional director, and Luis Neves, coordinator of the Direcção Central de Combate ao Banditismo in Lisbon, told them the case was now a murder inquiry.[141] When Encarnação died of stomach cancer in 2010, The Daily Telegraph identified him as a major source of the leaks against the McCanns.[142] Both the McCanns were interrogated that day; the officers suggested that Kate's memory was faulty.[141]

The FSS used a technique known as low copy number英语low copy number (LCN) testing. Used when only a few cells are available, the test is controversial because it is vulnerable to contamination and misinterpretation.[143] On 3 September, John Lowe of the FSS emailed Detective Superintendent Stuart Prior of the Leicestershire Police, the liaison officer between the British and Portuguese authorities. Lowe told Prior that a sample from the car boot contained fifteen out of nineteen of Madeleine's DNA components, and that the result was "too complex for meaningful interpretation":

A complex LCN [low copy number] DNA result which appeared to have originated from at least three people was obtained from cellular material recovered from the luggage compartment section ... Within the DNA profile of Madeleine McCann there are 20 DNA components represented by 19 peaks on a chart. ... Of these 19 components 15 are present within the result from this item; there are 37 components in total. There are 37 components because there are at least 3 contributors; but there could be up to five contributors. In my opinion therefore this result is too complex for meaningful interpretation/inclusion. ... [W]e cannot answer the question: Is the match genuine, or is it a chance match.[a]

McCanns made arguidos

编辑

Lowe's email was translated into Portuguese on 4 September 2007. The next day, according to Kate, the PJ proposed that, if she were to admit that Madeleine had died in an accident in the apartment and that she had hidden the body, she might only serve a two-year sentence. Her husband would not be charged and would be free to leave.[146] Both parents were given arguido status on 7 September,[147] and were advised by their lawyer not to answer questions. The PJ told Gerry that Madeleine's DNA had been found in the car boot and behind the sofa in apartment 5A.[148] Gerry did respond to questions, but Kate declined to reply to 48 questions she was asked during an eleven-hour interview.[149]

The DNA evidence was a "100 percent match", journalists in Portugal were told.[150] British tabloid headlines included "Corpse in McCann Car" (London Evening Standard, 16 October 2007), while the Daily Star reported that a "clump of Maddie's hair" had been found in the car.[151] The leaks came directly from Portuguese police, according to testimony in 2012 from Jerry Lawton, a Daily Star reporter, to the Leveson Inquiry英语Leveson Inquiry.[b] Matt Baggott of the Leicestershire Police told the inquiry that, because the Portuguese were in charge of the case, he had made a decision not to correct reporters; his force's priority, he said, was to maintain a good relationship with the PJ with a view to finding Madeleine.[153]{{efn|Matt Baggott英语Matt Baggott, former chief constable of Leicestershire Police英语Leicestershire Police (Leveson Inquiry英语Leveson Inquiry, 28 March 2012): "[A]s a chief constable at the time, there were a number of I think very serious considerations. One for me, and the Gold Group who were running the investigation, which was a UK effort, was very much a respect for the primacy of the Portuguese investigation. We were not in the lead in relation to their investigative strategy. We were merely dealing with enquiries at the request of the Portuguese and managing the very real issues of the local dimension of media handling, so we were not in control of the detail or the facts or where that was going.
"I think the second issue was there was an issue, if I recall, of Portuguese law. Their own judicial secrecy laws. I think it would have been utterly wrong to have somehow in an off the record way have breached what was a very clear legal requirement upon the Portuguese themselves....
"There was also an issue for us of maintaining a very positive relationship with the Portuguese authorities themselves. I think this was an unprecedented inquiry in relation to Portugal. The media interest, their own reaction to that. And having a very positive relationship of confidence with the Portuguese authorities I think was a precursor to eventually and hopefully one day successfully resolving what happened to that poor child.
"So the relationship of trust and confidence would have been undermined if we had gone off the record in some way or tried to put the record straight, contrary to the way in which the Portuguese law was configured and their own leadership of that."[154][155][156]

McCanns return to the UK, Almeida report

编辑

Despite their arguido status, the McCanns were allowed to leave Portugal, and on legal advice did so immediately, arriving back in England on 9 September 2007.[157] The following day Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida of the PJ in Portimão signed a nine-page report concluding that Madeleine had died in apartment 5A as a result of an accident, that the restaurant meal and apparent regular checks on the McCann children had been part of the cover-up英语cover-up, that the Tapas Seven had helped to mislead the police, and that the McCanns had concealed the child's body before faking an abduction. An eleven-page document from the Information Analysis Brigade in Lisbon analysed alleged discrepancies in the McCanns' statements.[158][70] On 11 September the public prosecutor, José Cunha de Magalhães e Meneses, handed the ten-volume case file to a judge, Pedro Miguel dos Anjos Frias.[159] Meneses applied for the seizure of Kate's diary and Gerry's laptop.[160] The police also wanted to trace telephone calls between the McCanns and the Tapas Seven, and there were details in the report about the number of suitcases the McCanns and their friends had taken back to England.[161]

On 28 September 2007, according to a diplomatic cable英语diplomatic cable published by WikiLeaks in 2010, the United States ambassador to Portugal, Al Hoffman, wrote about a meeting he had had with the British ambassador to Portugal, Alexander Ellis英语Alexander Ellis (diplomat), on 21 September 2007. The cable said: "Without delving into the details of the case, Ellis admitted that the British police had developed the current evidence against the McCann parents, and he stressed that authorities from both countries were working co-operatively. He commented that the media frenzy was to be expected and was acceptable as long as government officials keep their comments behind closed doors."[162]

Control Risks英语Control Risks Group, a British security company—paid by an anonymous donor to assist the McCanns since 7 May 2007[163]—took hair samples from the McCann twins on 24 September 2007, at their parents' request. The twins had slept through the commotion in apartment 5A after Madeleine was reported missing; Kate wrote that she was concerned the abductor might have given the children sedatives.[164] According to the PJ files, Kate had asked them to take samples, three months after the disappearance, but they had not done so.[165] Control Risks took a sample from Kate too, to rebut allegations that she was on medication. No trace of drugs was found.[166]

注释

编辑
  1. ^ The email from John Lowe (Forensic Science Service英语Forensic Science Service, 3 September 2007) continued: "The individual components in Madeleine's profile are not unique to her; it is the specific combination of 19 components that makes her profile unique above all others. Elements of Madeleine's profile are also present within the profiles of many of the scientists here in Birmingham, myself included. It's important to stress that 50% of Madeleine's profile will be shared with each parent. It is not possible, in a mixture of more than two people, to determine or evaluate which specific DNA components pair with each other. ... Therefore, we cannot answer the question: Is the match genuine, or is it a chance match."[144][145]
  2. ^ Jerry Lawton, Daily Star (Leveson Inquiry英语Leveson Inquiry, 19 March 2012): "Portuguese police leaked in briefings in Portugal to their journalists that the forensic test results positively showed that Madeleine had been in or linked her to the hire car that her parents didn't hire until three or four weeks after she'd disappeared, and that story became a—created a sea change, without overusing that word, in the way the story has been looked at.
    "Those forensic test results became a bone of contention between the UK and the Portuguese police. I was present when a Portuguese team of forensic experts and detectives arrived in Leicester to discuss these results. Of course, they'd already leaked a version of the results. Leicestershire police presumably knew—although it turns out obviously that those test results did not prove that and that the Portuguese police had somehow misinterpreted these results. I just felt that had this been—that Leicestershire police could have briefed, off the record, even unreportable, that the Portuguese police had misinterpreted those DNA results. ...
    "Every time you rang Leicestershire police on that inquiry—and it was a lot, from every media organisation—you were told: 'It's a Portuguese police inquiry. You'll have to contact the Portuguese police.' And of course, they were fully aware that the Portuguese police had judicial secrecy laws and they wouldn't talk about the case."[152]

参考文献

编辑
  1. ^ "Madeleine McCann, aged progressed to age nine"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), Scotland Yard; Patrick Barkham, "The sad ageing of Madeleine McCann"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Guardian, 25 April 2012.
  2. ^ "Master of media circus for Madeleine McCann"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Daily Telegraph, 24 April 2008.
  3. ^ 以下连结有显示公寓及餐厅之间的直接距离:"Kidnapping concern for missing girl in Portugal"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), Reuters, 4 May 2007; Kate McCann, Madeleine, Bantam Press, 2011 (hardback edition), p. 54.
  4. ^ Esther Addley, "Madeleine McCann: hope and persistence rewarded"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Guardian, 27 April 2012: "It was, the [Portuguese] attorney general found, largely due to a catastrophic misinterpretation of the evidence collected by ... [Leicestershire police] that the Portuguese team came to suspect the McCanns in the disappearance."
  5. ^ James Sturcke and agencies, "McCanns and Murat formally cleared in case of missing Madeleine"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Guardian, 21 July 2008.
  6. ^ 6.0 6.1 Sandra Laville, "British detectives release efits of Madeleine McCann suspect"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Guardian, 14 October 2013.
  7. ^ For Diana comparison, Nicola Rehling, "'Touching Everyone': Media Identifications, Imagined Communities and New Media Technologies in the Case of Madeleine McCann," in Ruth Parkin-Gounelas (ed.), The Psychology and Politics of the Collective: Groups, Crowds and Mass Identifications, Routledge 2012, p. 152ff.For Twitter, Eilis O'Hanlon, "Eilis O'Hanlon: The sad rise of cyber courts full of Twittering bullies"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), Sunday Independent (Ireland), 29 April 2012.Also see Brian Cathcart, "The Real McCann Scandal"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), New Statesman, 23 October 2008.
  8. ^ "Wednesday 23 November 2011; afternoon session" 英国政府互联网档案馆英语UK Government Web Archive存档,存档日期2014-01-22, Kate and Gerry McCann's testimony, Leveson Inquiry, from 08:40 mins; Transcript and witness statement of Gerry McCann页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆) and Kate McCann页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), Leveson Inquiry.
  9. ^ James Robinson, "Leveson inquiry: McCanns deliver damning two-hour testimony"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Guardian, 23 November 2011.
  10. ^ Madeleine McCann assumed dead - German prosecutors. 2020-06-04 [2020-06-07]. (原始内容存档于2020-09-30). 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆
  11. ^ missing child. [2021-02-08]. (原始内容存档于2007-08-24). 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), PJ.
  12. ^ Haroon Siddique, Madeleine McCann's parents release picture of how she might look now. [2021-02-08]. (原始内容存档于2018-11-05). 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Guardian, 1 May 2009.
  13. ^ Madeleine McCann: Police release new 'age progression' image. [2021-02-08]. (原始内容存档于2021-03-08). 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆) , The Daily Telegraph, April 2012.
  14. ^ McCann 2011,第7–10, 18–19页.
  15. ^ "Dr Gerry McCann"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), University of Leicester. Also see Spence 2007,第1168页.
  16. ^ McCann 2011,第17, 26, 37页.
  17. ^ 17.0 17.1 McCann 2011,第42页.
  18. ^ 18.0 18.1 Angela Balakrishnan, "Key players in the McCann case"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), The Guardian, 2008-04-10; "Who are the McCann tapas seven?"页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆), BBC News, 2008-10-16.
  19. ^ McCann 2011,第20页.
  20. ^ 20.0 20.1 McCann 2011,第76页.
  21. ^ 21.0 21.1 21.2 21.3 21.4 21.5 Judy Bachrach, "Unanswered Prayers" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期23 December 2020., Vanity Fair, October 2008.
  22. ^ 22.0 22.1 Caroline Gammell, "Madeleine McCann: Apartment was not made crime scene for two months" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期22 January 2018., The Daily Telegraph, 8 August 2008.
  23. ^ Angela Balakrishnan, "The resort that was rocked one night in May" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期1 March 2017., The Guardian, 11 April 2008.
  24. ^ McCann 2011,第45页.
  25. ^ DCI Andy Redwood, Crimewatch 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期16 February 2016., BBC, 14 October 2013, from 00:20:02.
  26. ^ 26.0 26.1 26.2 26.3 26.4 Angela Balakrishnan, "What happened on the day Madeleine disappeared?" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期13 February 2017., The Guardian, 11 April 2008.
  27. ^ "Searching for Madeleine" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期27 March 2015., Dispatches, Channel 4, 18 October 2007, 00:15:21.
  28. ^ "Searching for Madeleine" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期27 March 2015., Dispatches, 00:06:25.
  29. ^ McCann 2011,第62–64页.
  30. ^ Giles Tremlett, "McCanns release last picture of Madeleine before she vanished" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期20 December 2016., The Guardian, 25 May 2007.
    For 2:29 pm: Laura Roberts, "Madeleine McCann: Kate McCann fears outfit may have led to kidnap" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期11 October 2018., The Daily Telegraph, 11 May 2011.
  31. ^ McCann 2011,第67, 69页.
  32. ^ 32.0 32.1 32.2 32.3 McCann 2011,第69–70页.
  33. ^ For "50 metres (yards)", "Kidnapping concern for missing girl in Portugal" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期6 August 2020., Reuters, 4 May 2007.
    For 60 yards as the crow flies, and a 90-yard walk, "less than a minute's walk away", Summers & Swan 2014,第12页. Ninety yards would take a minute to walk at a speed of around three miles per hour.
  34. ^ McCann 2011,第56, 325页.
  35. ^ 35.0 35.1 Bridget O'Donnell, "My months with Madeleine" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期12 March 2017., The Guardian, 14 December 2007.
  36. ^ 36.0 36.1 36.2 36.3 36.4 36.5 36.6 36.7 36.8 Smith, David James. Kate and Gerry McCann: Beyond the smears. The Sunday Times. (原始内容存档于6 April 2016). 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆
  37. ^ "Reconstruction of Tanner sighting", "Madeleine was here", Cutting Edge, Channel 4 (UK), 10 May 2009, 4/5, 00:02:34 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期6 April 2017..
  38. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第85页.
  39. ^ Caroline Gammell, "Madeleine McCann: Map 'shows where abductor was spotted'" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期21 January 2019., The Daily Telegraph, 5 August 2008.
  40. ^ McCann 2011,第84页.
  41. ^ McCann 2011,第230, 273, 370页.
  42. ^ Michelle Pauli, "Is this Madeleine McCann's abductor?" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期16 September 2016., The Guardian, 26 October 2007.
    Martin Hodgson, "McCanns release sketch of man seen near apartment" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期16 September 2016., The Guardian, 26 October 2007.
  43. ^ 43.0 43.1 43.2 "Madeleine McCann: Police reveal 'pre-planned abduction' theory" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期2019-01-01., BBC News, 15 October 2013.
  44. ^ Peter Walker, "Madeleine McCann inquiry shifts as sighting found to be false lead" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期13 August 2016., The Guardian, 14 October 2013; Summers & Swan 2014,第254页.
  45. ^ DCI Andy Redwood, Crimewatch, BBC, 14 October 2013, from 00:21:16 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期5 April 2017..
  46. ^ DCI Andy Redwood, Crimewatch, BBC, 14 October 2013, from 00:23:27 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期5 April 2017..
    "Madeleine McCann: Few people rent apartment 5A since Maddie vanished" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期17 February 2017., Irish Independent, 5 May 2012.
  47. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为SundayTimes27Oct2013的参考文献提供内容
  48. ^ 48.0 48.1 48.2 McCann 2011,第98页.
  49. ^ "Madeleine was here", Cutting Edge, Channel 4 (UK), 10 May 2009, 4/5, 00:05:55; Crimewatch, BBC, 14 October 2013, from 00:23:35.
  50. ^ Patrick Counihan, "Irish couple key witnesses as British police launch new enquiry into Madeleine McCann case" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期3 November 2013., Irish Central, 14 October 2013.
  51. ^ 51.0 51.1 McCann 2011,第123页.
  52. ^ BBC Crimewatch, 14 October 2013, from 00:23:35.
  53. ^ McCann 2011,第71–73页; "Madeleine was here", Channel 4 Cutting Edge, 10 May 2009, 1/5 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期30 April 2015., 00:00:45.
  54. ^ McCann 2011,第74页.
  55. ^ "Searching for Madeleine" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期27 March 2015., Dispatches, Channel 4, 18 October 2007, 00:08:36; for the first search being abandoned at 4:30 am: 00:09:33.
  56. ^ McCann 2011,第75–76页.
  57. ^ 57.0 57.1 McCann 2011,第78页.
  58. ^ "Madeleine McCann: The evidence" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期14 April 2018., BBC News, 8 September 2007.
  59. ^ Polícia Judiciária files, cited in McCann 2011,第85页.
  60. ^ "Searching for Madeleine", Dispatches, Channel 4, 18 October 2007, 00:20:20.
  61. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Hamilos3Oct2007的参考文献提供内容
  62. ^ Steven Morris, "Q&A: Madeleine McCann" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期14 March 2022., The Guardian, 8 May 2007.
  63. ^ 63.0 63.1 Summers & Swan 2014,第237–328页.
  64. ^ Richard Edwards and Fiona Govan, "Maddy police ignored vital CCTV", The Daily Telegraph 19 May 2007.
  65. ^ "Madeleine evidence 'may be lost'" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期18 July 2007., BBC News, 17 June 2007.
  66. ^ Richard Edwards, "The 15 key blunders", The Daily Telegraph, 2 June 2007.
  67. ^ Collins 2008,第xxxi–xxxii页.
  68. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第48–49页; "Profile: Matt Baggott" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期3 March 2017., BBC News, 11 August 2009.
  69. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第48–49页.
  70. ^ 70.0 70.1 Fiona Govan, "Madeleine McCann's death 'covered up by parents who faked kidnap', court hears" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期1 November 2017., The Daily Telegraph, 12 January 2010.
  71. ^ "Madeleine McCann: A Global Obsession", Channel 5 (UK), 18 November 2014, 00:15:48 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期5 April 2017..
  72. ^ Ben Dowell, "McCanns' PR steps down" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期15 August 2016., The Guardian, 13 September 2007.
    Hannah Marriott, "Hanover calls time on McCanns" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期4 March 2017., PR Week, 21 November 2007; David Quainton, "McCanns still fine-tuning PR" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期4 March 2017., PR Week, 19 September 2007.
  73. ^ Giles Tremlett, "With prejudice" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期15 August 2016., The Guardian, 17 September 2007.
  74. ^ "Master of media circus for Madeleine McCann" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期4 May 2019., The Daily Telegraph, 24 April 2008.
  75. ^ McCann 2011,第148, 268页.
    Cole Morton, "Clarence Mitchell: 'I am a decent human being. If I can help them, I will'" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期25 June 2017., The Independent on Sunday, 1 March 2009.
  76. ^ "Madeleine McCann: A Global Obsession", Channel 5 (UK), 18 November 2014, 00:20:58 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期5 April 2017..
  77. ^ 77.0 77.1 Giles Tremlett and Brendan de Beer, "Parents of Madeleine to visit Pope in bid to spread hunt across Europe" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期4 March 2017., The Guardian, 28 May 2007.
  78. ^ McCann 2011,第178ff页; Fiona Govan, "Smiles as children greet McCanns in Morocco" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期11 October 2018., The Daily Telegraph, 12 June 2007.
  79. ^ "Balloons Soar for Missing British Girl" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期5 March 2017., Associated Press, 22 June 2007.
  80. ^ India Knight, "Lay off the McCanns", The Times, 3 June 2007.
    Kirsty Wark, "Madeleine and the media" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期7 March 2017., BBC News, 21 August 2007.
    Janice Turner, "Face it: we need the McCanns to be guilty" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期4 March 2017., The Times, 15 September 2007.{pb} Matthew Paris, interviewed for "Madeleine McCann: A Global Obsession", Channel 5 (UK), 18 November 2014, 00:19:07 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期5 April 2017..
  81. ^ Rehling 2012,第153页.
  82. ^ Jonathan Freedland, "Madeleine: a grimly compelling story that will end badly for us all" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期16 February 2017., The Guardian, 12 September 2007.
  83. ^ Machado & Prainsack 2016,第52–53页.
  84. ^ Kennedy 2010,第225, 227页.
  85. ^ 85.0 85.1 85.2 Giles Tremlett, "Madeleine disappearance: Briton's villa searched and three questioned by police" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期24 February 2017., The Guardian, 15 May 2007.
  86. ^ "Mild-mannered father who became first one accused" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期1 March 2017., Press Association, 1 May 2008.
    "Murat addresses Cambridge Union" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期13 December 2014., BBC News, 5 March 2009.
    "Robert Murat holds Cambridge Union spellbound in tabloids debate" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期2 December 2013., University of Cambridge, 6 March 2009.
  87. ^ 87.0 87.1 87.2 David James Smith, Steven Swinford and Richard Woods, "Victims of the rumour mill?", The Sunday Times, 9 September 2007.
  88. ^ "Profile: Robert Murat" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期22 December 2016., BBC News, 21 July 2008.
  89. ^ McCann 2011,第134–136页; Summers & Swan 2014,第89页; Haroon Siddique, "McCann friends confront Madeleine suspect" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期14 March 2022., The Guardian, 13 July 2007.
  90. ^ Gordon Rayner, "Madeleine witnesses cast doubt on Murat's alibi" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期3 July 2018., The Daily Telegraph, 31 December 2007.
  91. ^ Richard Bilton, "Madeleine McCann: 10 Years On", Panorama, BBC, 3 May 2017, 00:29:09.
  92. ^ "Russian denies links to Madeleine" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期25 October 2013., BBC News, 17 May 2007.
    "New Madeleine search draws blank" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期17 October 2007., BBC News, 6 August 2007.
  93. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第89页; "Murat friend quizzed over Madeleine finds car torched—and the word 'speak' scrawled beside it" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期8 March 2019., London Evening Standard, 21 March 2008.
  94. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Govan21July2008的参考文献提供内容
  95. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Townsend13April2008的参考文献提供内容
  96. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Beer1July2014的参考文献提供内容
  97. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Beer10December2014的参考文献提供内容
  98. ^ Rozina Sabur, "Key eyewitness says she saw young woman acting 'suspiciously' on night Madeleine McCann disappeared" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期30 December 2017., The Daily Telegraph, 3 May 2017.
  99. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Redwood 14 Oct, 2013 00:24:38的参考文献提供内容
  100. ^ Collins 2008,第202–203页; Summers & Swan 2014,第57–59页.
  101. ^ 101.0 101.1 DCI Andy Redwood, Crimewatch, BBC, 14 October 2013, from 00:30:45 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期2017-04-05..
  102. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第58页.
  103. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第58–59页.
  104. ^ McCann 2011,第373页.
  105. ^ 105.0 105.1 McCann 2011,第469–473页; "'Very ugly' new Madeleine suspect" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期2013-10-15., BBC News, 6 May 2009; "Madeleine was here 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期2017-04-06.", Cutting Edge, Channel 4, 10 May 2009, 3/5, 00:03:30; for the white van: 00:05:58.
  106. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第287–288页; McCann 2011,第375页.
  107. ^ BBC Crimewatch, 14 October 2013, 00:24:45.
  108. ^ Richard Edwards, "We're good parents not suspects, say McCanns" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期11 October 2018., The Daily Telegraph, 7 June 2007.
    José Manuel Oliveira, Paula Martinheira, "PJ teme que pista marroquina de Madeleine resulte em nada" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期7 March 2019., Diario de Noticias, 7 June 2007.
  109. ^ 109.0 109.1 McCann 2011,第189页.
  110. ^ Felicia Cabrita and Margarida Davim, "The Madeleine Case: A Pact of Silence", Sol, 30 June 2007; Summers & Swan 2014,第136–137页.
  111. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第136页.
  112. ^ 112.0 112.1 Witness statements, Gerry McCann, Polícia Judiciária, Portimão, 4 May 2007 and 10 May 2007.
  113. ^ Chief Inspector Tavares de Almeida, Polícia Judiciária, report to the coordinator of the investigation, 10 September 2007, Polícia Judiciária files, vol X, 2587–2602.
  114. ^ 114.0 114.1 Collins 2008,第211–212页.
  115. ^ Witness statement, Gerry McCann, Polícia Judiciária, Portimão, 10 May 2007; McCann 2011,第73页.
  116. ^ David Brown, "Puzzles and mysteries at the very heart of the investigation" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期23 February 2017., The Times, 10 September 2007.
  117. ^ Collins 2008,第208–212页.
  118. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Rayner26April2016的参考文献提供内容
  119. ^ Victoria Burnett, "As a Child Disappears, Old Headlines Howl Again" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期13 February 2017., The New York Times, 18 September 2007.
  120. ^ Richard Bilton, "Madeleine: The Last Hope?" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期13 February 2017., BBC Panorama, 25 April 2012, 00:14:33.
  121. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第140页. Also see Ben Goldacre, "After Madeleine, why not Bin Laden?" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期23 February 2017., The Guardian, 13 October 2007.
  122. ^ McCann 2011,第186–187, 197, 199页.
  123. ^ 123.0 123.1 Mark Townsend and Ned Temko, "Forensic DNA tests 'reveal traces of Madeleine's body on resort beach'" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期22 February 2017., The Guardian, 7 October 2007.
  124. ^ Gonçalo Amaral, quoted in Summers & Swan 2014,第141页.
  125. ^ 125.0 125.1 Summers & Swan 2014,第141–142页.
  126. ^ "Judge admits Madeleine's case was at a 'dead end' in December –but it took another 7 months to clear McCanns" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期2 July 2017., London Evening Standard, 12 August 2008.
  127. ^ Brendan McDaid, "Top sniffer dog to join Maddy search" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期21 October 2014., Belfast Telegraph, 8 August 2007.
    For information on Keela: Top Dog. South Yorkshire Police. (原始内容存档于14 January 2008). 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆
  128. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第147–148页.
  129. ^ 129.0 129.1 Keela and Eddie in 5A 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期6 April 2017.; In the car park and 5A 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期5 April 2017., Polícia Judiciária, August 2007, released 11 August 2008, courtesy of YouTube.
  130. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第149页.
  131. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第149–150页.
  132. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第150–152页.
  133. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第150页.
  134. ^ Caroline Gammell, "Madeleine McCann's parents look to US sniffer dog case" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期12 November 2017., The Daily Telegraph, 17 August 2007.
  135. ^ McCann 2011,第241页; Summers & Swan 2014,第152页
  136. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第152–153页.
  137. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第153页.
  138. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第153页; Andrew Alderson and Tom Harper, "The allegations facing the McCanns" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期12 November 2017., The Daily Telegraph, 9 September 2007.
  139. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第154–156页.
  140. ^ Sandra Laville, "UK lab to test blood found in Madeleine room" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期14 March 2022., The Guardian, 7 August 2007.
  141. ^ 141.0 141.1 Summers & Swan 2014,第158页.
  142. ^ 引用错误:没有为名为Mendick6March2010的参考文献提供内容
  143. ^ Machado and Santos 2011 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期7 March 2019., 312–313; for background, see "Low Copy Number DNA testing in the Criminal Justice System" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期28 June 2013., Crown Prosecution Service, cps.gov.uk.
  144. ^ John Lowe, Forensic Science Service, Birmingham, email to Detective Superintendent Stuart Prior, Leicestershire police, 3 September 2007, released 4 August 2008.
  145. ^ James Orr, Brendan de Beer and agencies, "UK police warned on DNA evidence before McCanns became suspects" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期16 September 2016., The Guardian, 4 August 2008; McCann 2011,第331页.
  146. ^ McCann 2011,第243页.
  147. ^ James Sturcke and James Orr, "Kate McCann 'fears Madeleine killing charge over blood traces in car'" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期7 March 2022., The Guardian, 7 September 2007.
  148. ^ Caroline Gammell, "Madeleine McCann: Portuguese detectives lied to Gerry McCann about DNA evidence" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期31 December 2017., The Daily Telegraph, 4 August 2008.
  149. ^ "The questions put to Kate McCann" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期15 February 2009., BBC News, 6 August 2008; McCann 2011,第248页.
  150. ^ Gordon Rayner, Caroline Gammell and Nick Britten, "Madeleine McCann DNA 'an accurate match'" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期26 December 2017., The Daily Telegraph, 12 September 2007.
  151. ^ "Searching for Madeleine", Dispatches, Channel 4, 18 October 2007, 00:41:10; for the Evening Standard, Goc 2009,第39页.
  152. ^ Lawton 2012,第85–89页.
  153. ^ Lisa O'Carroll, "Leveson inquiry: ex-police chief defends not preventing false McCann DNA reports" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期16 September 2016., The Guardian, 28 March 2012.
  154. ^ Matt Baggott: transcript of testimony (PDF). Leveson Inquiry: afternoon hearing, 68–71; also see 76–83. 28 March 2012. 原始内容存档于21 October 2012. 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆
  155. ^ Matt Baggott. Leveson Inquiry: afternoon hearing (video), from 104:38 and 115:22. 28 March 2012. 原始内容存档于17 October 2013. 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆
  156. ^ Matt Baggott's witness statement (PDF). Leveson Inquiry: question 50, 22–25. 原始内容存档于21 October 2012. 页面存档备份,存于互联网档案馆
  157. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第170页; "Madeleine parents back in Britain" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期12 January 2009., BBC News, 9 September 2007.
  158. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第172–173页.
  159. ^ Caroline Gammell, "Madeleine judge is known as a tough character" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期11 October 2018., The Daily Telegraph, 12 September 2007.
  160. ^ Caroline Gammell, "Police seek McCanns' laptop to read emails" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期11 October 2018., The Daily Telegraph, 12 September 2007.
  161. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第173页.
  162. ^ Ben Quinn, "WikiLeaks cables: UK police 'developed' evidence against McCanns" 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期23 February 2017., The Guardian, 13 December 2010.
    For the date of the meeting, "US embassy cables: British police 'developed evidence' against McCanns, Washington told " 互联网档案馆存档,存档日期23 February 2017., The Guardian, 13 December 2010.
  163. ^ David Brown and Patrick Foster, "Private security team hired by Kate and Gerry McCann for secret investigation", The Times, 24 September 2007.
  164. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第213–214页; McCann 2011,第213–214页.
  165. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第165页.
  166. ^ Summers & Swan 2014,第213–214页; Fiona Govan, "Madeleine McCann's mother takes drug test", The Daily Telegraph, 23 November 2007.

参考书籍

编辑

外部链接

编辑